Estimated read time: 5-6 minutes
This archived news story is available only for your personal, non-commercial use. Information in the story may be outdated or superseded by additional information. Reading or replaying the story in its archived form does not constitute a republication of the story.
SALT LAKE CITY — Five women and one man who have accused Operation Underground Railroad founder Tim Ballard of sexual assault in several lawsuits revealed their identities and spoke publicly with reporters for the first time Tuesday.
In a tearful, lengthy interview in Salt Lake City, the plaintiffs explained their desire to help the cause of ending human trafficking. Many said they did not want to take their stories to the public but felt an obligation to try to prevent others from being victimized in the same way they allege they were.
One of the plaintiffs, Kira Lynch, said it was "humiliating to share the most mortifying moments of my life publicly, but it had to be done to put a stop to this. To Tim Ballard and OUR: The truth is finally coming to light and the evil, the pure evil, can no longer hide."
Several of the women allege Ballard manipulated and groomed them while having them pose as their girlfriend or wife while on undercover missions. Ballard has explained the so-called "couples ruse" used to fool traffickers and has vehemently denied any allegations of sexual misconduct.
Sasha Hightower described Ballard's denials as "triggering," and Lynch called them "devastating."
"We don't want him to hurt anyone," she added.
"I feel infuriated, but I also feel terrified that that narrative will rule, and that will become the truth," said Bree Righter, another one of the plaintiffs. "Because it's gaslighting on a global scale. And if he, and frankly OUR (and) the Spear Fund aren't stopped, this could continue. That's what we're scared of."
The Spear Fund is a separate anti-trafficking organization where Ballard has served as a senior adviser since leaving Operation Underground Railroad this summer. The Spear Fund has previously provided statements denying the allegations against Ballard but did not respond to a request for comment on this story.
Mike Borys, another plaintiff, called Ballard an "evil man," and a "bully (who) has been allowed to carry out his disgusting deeds for far too long." He said the plaintiffs aren't trying to hurt the cause of human trafficking — as Ballard has argued in previous statements and on his podcast.
"We are not members of some cartel looking to undermine the cause of saving children," he said. "We are not 'pedophile enablers.' We are not the 'deep state' or the 'godless left.' These are wives, and these are mothers, who wanted desperately to help the cause they so deeply believed in."
Borys and his wife, Celeste Borys, are married but separated because of this experience, they say.
"I wanted to help fight the bad guys," said Celeste Borys, another plaintiff. "Instead, I became a target for the worst guys."
The group also accuses Operation Underground Railroad and its board of protecting Ballard when the women reported they had been sexually assaulted.
Plaintiff Mary Hall said it's scary to come forward publicly, but said, "I believe in truth and letting light shine through."
"I will not allow OUR or Tim Ballard to treat anyone else the way that I was treated," Lynch said.
New lawsuit
In response to a lawsuit filed Monday by Righter, an Operation Underground Railroad spokesperson said the group "will defend the organization against the plaintiff's misguided attempts to create confusion by painting a false narrative about OUR."
"The current leadership of OUR has increased its commitment to provide a safe, respectful and harassment-free environment, and we are deeply sorry for any harm or distress that Tim Ballard's actions may have caused to anyone associated with OUR," the statement continues.
In that lawsuit, Righter said she was sexually assaulted while working with Operation Underground Railroad and suffered a fractured orbital bone during a training exercise with the organization.
The lawsuit describes Matthew Cooper as a "current or former employee of OUR ... and resident of the state of Utah" who "had actual knowledge of Ballard's and/or OUR's misconduct." On an episode of his podcast published on Aug. 16, Ballard said Cooper was the "very first person" he hired after starting Operation Underground Railroad, and said Cooper accompanied him on "all of the major operations," including one depicted in the film "Sound of Freedom."
Righter alleges in the suit that she was required to visit a strip club in Salt Lake City in order to "prove herself" to Ballard and Cooper ahead of an operation in the British Virgin Islands.
The lawsuit describes the mission as a "fishing trip" which "had no clear or discernible purpose." While in the British Virgin Islands, "Ballard attempted to goad defendant Cooper to be more sexually aggressive in the couples ruse with plaintiff, which led to plaintiff being sexually touched by defendant Cooper under false pretense both at the lavish resort and while going to strip clubs and massage parlors," the complaint states.
A person familiar with the matter confirmed that Cooper is no longer with Operation Underground Railroad. Cooper did not respond to a request for comment and attempts to reach him through the organization were unsuccessful.
After the operation, Righter said she decided not to work with Operation Underground Railroad again, but was convinced to attend a four-day training in Salt Lake City. As a trained Marine and licensed clinical social worker, Righter said she agreed because she wanted to help save children from trafficking. However, she described the training — which took place Oct. 16, 2021 — as a "ruse," and said it was filmed to convince donors of Operation Underground Railroad's legitimacy.
During the training, she was "struck in the face by two untrained operators involved in cosplay training that was not part of any (operation) strategy," the lawsuit alleges. She suffered an orbital blowout fracture, but claims Ballard, who was present, "refused to call an ambulance because he wanted no record of the event occurring at OUR's training."
A spokesperson for Operation Underground Railroad denied allegations in the lawsuit that the organization is the "alter ego of Tim Ballard."
"While Tim Ballard was the public face of the organization during his tenure as CEO, he directly participated in less than 1% of OUR's operations between January 2020 and his departure in June 2023, and his operations were not representative of the vast majority of OUR's work," the statement continued. "OUR is currently conducting, on average, five commissions per week, which include a combination of boots on the ground, intelligence gathering, and contributing resources to law enforcement worldwide."
Contributing: Lindsay Aerts
